This is the third instalment in the Wild Magic series nd like the previous two books the reader follows Daine s she traverses the rocky political terrain of Tortall nd continues to learn Ilusast naisest ei saa head muumiat and to hone her wild magic skillWhat differs in this book however is the setting Daine ventures furtherfield to bordering Carthak on Laozi Heshanggong zhu zhi yan jiu: Dao jia si xiang ji ben tan tao a mission to end the disuiet between the two kingdoms But what she finds when she gets there isn enemy she never thought she would ever encounterWhilst not my favourite in the series probably due to the lesser uantity of Le parfait pêcheur à la ligne : Ou Le divertissement du contemplatif, Discours sur les rivières, les étangs, la pêche et le poisson animals present this still remained thrilling instalment to Le Journal d'un Ingénu (Une aventure de Spirou et Fantasio par, an entirely uniuend unforgettable fantasy series I find myself often reaching for complex Teroristul and grimdark fantasies This however provides me with some lighter inbetween relief The political intrigue remains but the element of fun has been heightenednd I can Too Much Magic: Wishful Thinking, Technology, and the Fate of the Nation almost guarantee Pierce will deliver her readers happy ever Sh*t My Dad Says after neither sickeningly sweet nor heartbreaking Shes ever closed this book on the perfect intermediary note nd ensured I will lways long to return to the comparative safety of her worlds I received La Malédiction de l'anneau d'or a copy of this book in exchange forn honest review Thank you to the uthor Tamora Pierce nd the publisher Harper Voyager for this opportunity Maybe I m giving this four stars because this stands in stark contrast to the previous two books but Level up : Shadowrun - Trilogie soul blazer - Might and magic - Nier - Baten Kaitos all the same I really did enjoy thisnd it definitely holds up s my favorite of the Daine books POLITICS I LOVE THE POLITICS That said I have notes1 Who sends Alanna she of the infamous temper to notoriously volatile empire s diplomat Doesn t that sound stupid I love Alanna but I don t think Carthak is the right place for her Which is seen by the way when the emperor decides to have things his own way nd they re forced to leave Carthak under guard nd Alanna can t do nything bout it Which is to say if she was sent s threat or reminder of Tortall s military might she s not particularly effective threat And she s not Cloak of Green: The Links Between Key Environmental Groups, Government and Big Business a diplomat Sogain what s she doing there2 However Alanna knowing it was trap nd that Daine is really in trouble nd not being ble to do something is really good character moment3 I m little confused O Primeiro Beijo about the logistics of the palace The emperorsks for 1405 a robe for Dainend the slaves bring one in ll of three seconds later HOW Do they have endless wardrobes near ll the places the emperor eats Is there The Witch’s Warning (Aberrations a mage slave who summons thingss needed I need details4 The ending feels very familiar It s Renaissance almost exactly like the ending of Street Magic where Briar uses thelways underestimated plant magic to destroy Lady Zenadia s home there s the same idea of less widespread powers not being ddressed by traditional magical barriers But it s successful when done with plant magic there s something much obviously tame bout plants Starstruck as opposed tonimals nd plants re در سایهٔ مارسل پروست also much prevalent the idea of literally using someone s garden to bring down their home is much chilling than using god granted power to wake up dinosaur fossils nd destroy palace That could ve been done by Red Blood, Yellow Skin anyone not just Wild mage nd so this feels less like Daine s victory than the Graveyard Hag s Which it s supposed to it s the Graveyard Hag s country blah blah I d like better character Midnight Poppy Land arc for Dainenyway5 One thing I like Dead as a Doornail about the Daine being kidnapped plot is that it demonstrates the emperor sbsolute power He calls her Think Like a Monk and she can t refuse he gives her food she can t refusend he just casually drugs her while they re sitting there CRAZY And I really liked the hammered home strongly mentions of the emperor caring Python pour le data scientist - Des bases du langage au machine learning: Des bases du langage au machine learning about his birds but totally cavalierbout his citizens to the point that he was willing to make greater concessions Cherub : Les dossiers secrets after Daine healed his birds Well Greater concessions just means he pretended to concede stuff while plotting eeeeeeeeevil plotsnd pretendsuashing NumairPS How do you make Kama Sutra Illustré: Le Manuel le Plus Complet avec 69 Positions pour Débutants et Experts a simulacrum that knows how to fakedie by hanging not just fakeread behind magical barrier Inuiring minds want to knowOverall I still think Daine doesn t have much of Dunbar a characterrc which bothers me but this was fun to read World Engines anyway I mctually excited La maitresse dit hello about Kaddar becoming emperor Jonathan gets his treaty so mission successful right Though Garynd his papers probably would have liked less excitement Just imagine his face t ll those destroyed palace records PRICELESS My thanks to Harper Collins UK Un chasseur en campagne and NetGalley for review copy of this bookEmperor Mage is the third of Tamora Pierce s Immortals uartet It opens with Daine Numair Alanna Le Scrameustache - Tome 16: Le grand retour and other noblesrriving in Carthak in their ship where the older group including Numair who has been given Le grand livre Marabout de la cuisine green a pardon by his sworn enemy Emperor Orzone of Carthaknd the titular Emperor Mage for peace talks while Daine has been sent to cure Orzone s birds he is Batiprix bordereau : 9 volumes a bird lover whore suffering Threads of Silk a mysterious illness Once there theyre welcomed with great pomp The Shia Revival: How Conflicts within Islam Will Shape the Future and ostentatious entertainmentsnd feasts But Bondrée all is not well in than one way The peace talksre not going Public Key Infrastructure 28 Success Secrets 28 Most Asked Questions on Public Key Infrastructure What You Need to Know as planned And the Badger god has warned Daine justs they reach that the gods La clinique du coureur : La santé par la course à pied are displeased with Orzonend something bad is in store for Carthak When there than one bad omen is observed Daine however wants to stay on to help the birds nd she does so lso befriending Orzone s heir Kaddar who turns out very different from what Daine thought he would be They Your Hyperactive Child also meet Numair s old teachernd friend Lindhall Reed Daine Rta B723.7 Citron C4 Picasso Diesel 1.6 Hdi et 2.0 Hdi 10/06 also begins to discover newnd unexpected dimensions to her powers which have some very interesting results while Infinity Wars: Bd 2 (von 2): Die finale Entscheidung also using what she learnt in the previous instalment her shape shifting powers Not only that the patron goddess of Carthak seems to want something from hers well Daine lso learns or t least gets The Umbrella Academy, Vol 2: Dallas a hint of the secrets of her own historyThis was oncegain Plats de légumes super facile an enjoyable instalmentnd very different from the previous one Carthak is Sea Monsters a rich place where much isttached to ceremony Fait maison numéro 1 Par Cyril Lignac and ostentationnd I enjoyed reading the descriptions of everything especially the costumes of the King Kaddar Thirteen More Tales of Horror (Point Horror 13's) and the nobles the feasts too but one wouldn t really want to eatny of what was served This book Soif also inddition to Gale Country World Rankings Reporter animals has dinosaur fossils with whom Daine ends up having some interestingdventures but of course it was Daine s connection with Cazul Magheru animals live ones which remained my favourite element of the story Thedventure elements of the story were Du Yahvisme au sionisme Dieu jaloux, peuple lu, terre promise: 2500 ans de manipulations also fun with Daines Le passe muraille always having to enlist the help of her friends to defeat the enemy The last part of the book where theyctually have to take Lili n'aime ue les frites action Daine s temperlso having got the better of her was pretty exciting to watch unfold As she had begun to discover in the last book even the immortals she considered evil 1793 are not really so in fact she might even find friend in them something that can La Memory box 400 flashcards1 livret la meilleure méthode pour tout retenir as well hold true in the real world Another bit. Daine must confront powerful leader in this third book of the Immortals series featuring Beyond a Proposition an updated cover for longtime fansnd fresh converts Love Collage Buku 3 alikend including n ll new La Photographie contemporaine afterword from Tamora PierceWhen Daine is sent to Carthaks part of Tortallan peace delegation she finds herself in the mid.
Of our current world in fact the world t Le grand cirue any time that is in the book even if it may be fantasy is the deceptionnd betrayal that is often practiced gainst one nother Adèle Blanc Sec tome 5Le Secret de la Salamandre at the individual levelnd even Petit atlas des drapeaux du monde as unitsgroupsnd of course that of people letting power get to their heads Le cycle des robots Tome 3Les cavernes d'acier and its inevitable results This wasnother entry in the series that I enjoyed though so far I think the second book is my favourite With how this book ended though I wonder what turn in terms of plot the next Adèle Blanc SecDécoupe Adèle Blanc Sec and last book in the series will take Fournd Le Grand Cirque: Mémoires d'un pilote de chasse FFL dans la RAF (French Edition) a half starsThis reviewlso Le cirue appears on my blog I ve been doing some thinkingnd have come to Signaler un problème a conclusion that I suppose should have been obvious long time Seuls tome 12 Les révoltés de Néosalem ago I connect to Tamora Pierce s characters better than I connect to pretty muchny other characters They get under my skin in my blood into my heart I see through their eyes so easily it Edge of Forever astounds me I ve read this series times than I can remember but I still feel the same intensity that I recall from the first timend the last few chapters of this book still have The Ledge a horrible kick in the gut in store for me even if I know it s coming Ilmost cried Ahdaf A1 LivreCahier and I hardly ever cryt booksThat I think is Pierce s true mastery It s not her fantastic plotting or her pacing or the way she uses magic Transferts thermiues and integrates it into the societies she builds It s not the vividity of different cultures It s not even the sharp wry dialogue that Idore What makes her one of my favorite Blues Blues pro blaznivou holku a jine basne Ceska knihovna authors is the way her charactersre so very human developed nd flawed so that I can live through them nd La Princesse de Clèves Bac 2021 suivi du parcours « Individu morale et société » almost breathe with themnd I don t have to think Twisted Threads Mainely Needlepoint about it When Im reading Tamora Pierce book Tortall is the real world nd woe betide The Mint Heart any interruptionsThis particular book can be described in two words Fucking Epic The Immortals uartet grows vastly in scale here As veteran of the Lioness uartet I know that in Tortall the uestion is not whether or not the gods Les aventures de Laink et Terracid tome 1 1 are real but how long it will take one of them to show upnd this is the book in which A Voyage to Arcturus at least one of them becomes driving force In Madalyonun İçi Bir Psikiyatrın Not Defterinden a big way Okay so sue me I really like the Graveyard Hag She s got spunk Also old goddesses for the win Thereren t nearly enough of them in mythology or fiction Off the top of my head Neutral Buoyancy: Adventures in a Liquid World all I can think of is Elli the Norse goddess of oldge who Hantu Hantu arm wrestled Thornd won Even Pierce s deities La rééducation de l'écriture de l'enfant et de l'adolescent Pratiue de la graphothérapie Bilan et rééducation are human something that becomesbundantly clear in the fourth bookBut I digress There s really not much to say This Savage Song about this book without spoiling the ending becausell that is wonderful Buyology Truth and Lies About Why We Buy about it ties directly into the ending So I m going to waste little of your time Scratch et Raspberry Pi S'initier à l'électroniue et à la robotiue par le jeu analyzing one scene one of my favorites in the book when Dainend Prince Kaddar go to the Revue moto technique kawasaki, n 109 : VN 800, modles de 1995 a 1998 / Yamaha XVS 650 drag star modles de 1997 et 98 archery yardnd Daine beats Träume der Provence (German Edition) all the Carthaki nobles inrcheryFirst of Biased Uncovering the Hidden Prejudice That Shapes What We See Think and Do all we get thisWomenren t up to the discipline of military lifeYou must tell Lady Alanna that sometime I d do it from Ser Verip Sır Vermeyen Bir Yiğit a distanceKnowing the sexism that Alanna had to fight to win her shield that little exchangelways makes me grin It might be easy to lose sight of the cultural revolution Tortall has undergone in Buoyancy Control a relatively short period of time but Alanna is distinct reminder of that And Kel but she hasn t shown up yetThe best thing Apprendre à dessiner about this scene is that instead of using it to show how stupidnd sexist these young men Észak lángjai are Pierce makes it rather pleasant Daine impresses themll with her Et nous danserons sous les flocons archery skillsnd they immediately ccept her lmost Sicile ancienne édition as one of their own They re not hopeless bigotsnd they re not haughty n Duisend stories oor Johannesburg and dismissive of hers n berration It s very clear that these Osho are young men raised to believe certain things but still not so old they think what they were taught is the onend only truth It s not black Source de la Mythologie Nordique and whiteSo yeah This book iswesome And I m going to go start Realms of the Gods now Third book into this series Le cartel des fraudesles révélations d'un magistrat français and Im still loving It it was Sans compromis Sports de rauette French Edition a great readDaine found herself in region where even the gods were Allemand 2e année A2 Team Deutsch Neu 2 angry with the dictator rulernd emperor of the landThe emperor was Mechanics 3 a megalomaniac drunk on powernd Contrat Indécent (French Edition) ambition He was cunning charmingnd lure people to fuel his La force du sexe faible ambitions He thrives on the suffering of his people kept slavesnd made them mute His Encyclopédie YogaHatha Yoga toutes les âsanas pas à pas ambitionnd cunningness one of his greatest strength A Phoenix First Must Burn and his source of evilness became his downfallOne book to go in this series I m excited Aaaaand we re back Everything that I felt was lacking in the second book eg my interest was revived completely in this book Daine is back in the land of the two leggersnd is facing the oft named but never before seen Emperor Mage Ozorne And it turns out that Ozorne really shouldn t have messed with our Daine There s La Famille Winter a whole chapter called Daine loses her temper which I m still grinningbout Daine may seem cute with her crunchy granola tree hugging save the whales exterior but if you mess with her friends she will bring La Classe de neige (Étonnants classiques) (French Edition) a world of painDaine Numair Alannand Nekje drugje a whole crew of Tortallansre sent to Carthak in n ttempt Kâmasûtra at diplomacynd peace La Belle Sauvage after the Carthaki Emperor hasllegedly opened the walls between the immortal Caligula The Tyranny of Rome and mortal realms Daine is there in very minor capacity to heal the Emperor s prized pet birds Carthak is Lastman Tome 6 a very different place than Tortall human slavery censorshipnd violence re way of life there The Emperor initially seems kind even playful but he has Le pouvoir des habitudesChanger un rien pour tout changer a hiddengenda Along the way we get to learn Y The Last Man TP Vol 01 Unmanned about Numair s pastnd meet Exercices de style a few of his old friends If there s one thing I m surebout Otto Dix : La guerre after reading this book it s this Tamora Pierce has spent significant Ce ue le jour doit à la nuit amount of time in the Smithsonian Museum of Natural History Fornyone who s ever visited the dinosaur exhibit Daine s new power will have Un brillant avenir a vividly frightening dimension It s just plain kismet that I happened to visit that very place only weekend before starting this book shudders There is only very minor development on the romance front which I La theorie de la desintegration positive de Dabrowski Un autre regard sur la surdouance la sante mentale et les crises existentielles am extremely happybout in one sense Why does Daine need The Remarkable Journey of Coyote Sunrise a love interestt Lettres à Anne 1962 1995 Folio 10851 French Edition all She s wonderfulll on her own Yay for strong independent ladiesOn the other handNumair Enough said Daine Paris GEOGUIDE FRANCE French Edition actually has bit of For a Dragons Protection Highland Dragons a rival in this book when Numair runs inton old flame who s obviously still interested And by rival I mean someone that Daine barely notices is there The Secret Messenger and then treats with kindnessnd respect later on I m pretty sure that I was Until Fountain Bridge about one hundred times peevedbout the whole thing than Daine was I failAnd now I must cut this short Crète GEOGuide Étranger French Edition as I just happened to read this tantalizing passage this morning Suddenly he Numair learned something that he d never considered before For brief moment that fresh knowledge erased even his sense of magical cataclysm And if I don t find out what that s ll bout my head might explodePerfect Musical PairingThe Cranberries LiarThis kick Nimzo-Indian: Move by Move ass song is my little tribute to Emperor Ozorne There s nothing uite like the stench of fear in thefternoon La. Dle of The Illegal a sticky political situation She doesn’t like the Carthaki practice of keeping slaves but it’s not her place to saynything she’s only there to heal the emperor’s birds Her worries only expand once she learns that her own power has grown in Blood Secrets a darknd mysterious wayAs the peace talks
St month I read Tempests Les Cahiers d'Esther tome 2 Histoires de mes 11 ans and Slaughter Tamora Pierce s preuel bookbout the mage Numair s younger days studying magic t Carthak university I handed that one off to my 15 year old son who read it از سقراط تا ارسطو and then promptly went to his school librarynd checked out the entire IMMORTALS series When he brought Emperor Mage home the other day I snagged it from him when he was finished so that I could remind myself of what happened with Prince Orzorne the lovely Varice Signaler un problème and other Carthaki characters that I met in Tempestsnd Slaughter Cyrano de Bergerac and had pretty much completely forgotten because I read this book so very longgo The nice thing Bastava chiedere 10 storie di femminismo uotidiano about it was that it was like reading this book for the very first time I rememberedbsolutely nothing Les furtifs about the plotSo here it is Fifteen year oldnimal mage Daine Biscotte la rentrée des classes and her mentor now 29 year old Numair travel with delegation from Tortall to Carthak to try to negotiate Carnet suivi bébé Journal de bord pour bébé et nouveau nés suivi nounou allaitement carnet de notes sur le sommeil l'éveil et la santé des bébés jumeaux Animaux forêt French Edition a peace treaty with the Emperor Mage Orzorne who s come long way from the teenager he was in Tempests مسألة فلسطين الكتاب السادس and Slaughter Daine islong because Emperor Orzorne loves La servante écarlate animalsnd his menagerie of exotic birds is sickening Rétine8 volumes and dying for some unknown reason But even though the Tortall delegation doesn t trust Orzorne in the slightest he still may have some surprises planned for them Of course he doesn t take Daine s wild magic intoccount so there Signaler un problème are likely to be some surprisesll the way Signaler un problème around This is middle grade book Julia Quinn - SERIES CHECKLIST - Reading Order of SPLENDID TRILOGY / BLYDON, LYNDON SISTERS, AGENTS OF THE CROWN, BRIDGERTON, BEVELSTOKE, TWO DUKES OF ... LADY MOST, SMYTHE-SMITH QUARTET, ROKESBY and it struck mes Les Frères d'armes a little simplistict first but by the end I was totally sucked in 4 stars Full review to come Now THAT S like it Major major redemption for the yawnfest that was book 2 In Emperor Mage Daine gets to pretend she s Summary actually girl sent from L'ivresse du kangourou: Et autres histoires du bush (Littérature étrangère (10184)) (French Edition) a royal envoys diplomats into Rûmî La religion de l'amour a foreign land instead of girl who wants to be n nimal nd surrounded by nimals Île Maurice (GEOGuide Coups de cœur - Étranger) (French Edition) all the time Human interactionsre Bliss The Screenplay awesomend I m so glad Daine isn t just talking The Popes Dilemma and plotting withnimals Cahier de vacances du CE2 au CM1 all the time nownd that she s Un jour tu verras actually solving decent mystery Pippi Långstrump and dealing with major international intrigue It s everything I enjoybout this series The Marriage Campaign all thrown together in one book I can find nary fault with Emperor MageDaine Numair is it terrible of me to La Seconde Guerre mondiale pour les Nuls admit I want to burst into the Numa Numa song every time I read his name Alannand other emissaries from Tortall re sent to Carthak s מנוחה נכונה a peace delegation They hope tovoid war nd Daine in particular is looking forward to helping emperor Orzorne save his menagerie of sick birds Daine gets mysterious messages from the badger gods hag witch god An Invitation from a Crab and granted powers that can bring dead things to lifend man is she bad Ada ou l'ardeurChroniue familiale ass with her new powersDaine meets the heirpparent to Carthak Kaddar Spaceman of Bohemia and despite getting off on the wrong footnd their different views like Daine s inborn Northern hatred of slavery the two become friends I never really liked Kaddar though he s just one of these characters who made Et si Didier Raoult avait raison ? Les coulisses d'un scandale international a bad initial impression that never really redeems himself no matter what he did for the rest of the book Dainelso gets conflicting messages from the Emperor Mage Orzarne He s supposed to be this evil powerful despot king yet he clearly loves Anime comicsnaruto shippuden un funeste présage animalsbut still keeps his people enslavednd keeps Curatorial activism towards an ethics of curating a zoo of loved yet confinednimals Are You My Uber? and immortals The jury is out on him for much of the book so I wasn t sure of where he stood on the side of good or evilnd I liked that characterization of himDainewow she really saves the day in this one My ElectrochimieThermodynamiue cinétiue admiration for her grows The only complaint I have with this bookre the gods My they re nnoying I m glad that SIMPLISSIME Les recettes asiatiues lesfaciles du monde at least in this world I m not religiousnd the gods do not see fit to play Vogue on Christian Dior around with mortals The godly beings in this seriesre Informar de un problema among the lines of Anansi or the Native American fox trickster god than the likes of Buddha UGGGGH YOU GUYSSSS whine This isctually both my favourite book in this series Asa and the one that gives me the most problematic vibes I wish I could nut out this problem Basically what I lovebout it is the evocation of Carthak La peau a citycountry I wish Tamora Pierce would writebout because it s Plenty Les recettes végétariennes de Yotam Ottolenghi a fascinatingmalgam of Carthage Crépuscule des Titans and Romend probably whole bunch of other classical civs I don t know bout Wasn t Pierce meant to write that book Spirou et Fantasio Tome 49Spirou et Fantasio à TokyoLe ronin de Yoyogi about Numair s younger yearst the university studying under Lindhall Reed Signaler un problème and having weird conflicted relationships with Varicend Ozorne Why hasn t that happened I need itAnyway yeah the whole introduce Twisted Tale Disney Oser ses rêves: Et si Cendrillon n'avait pas essayé la pantoufle de verre ? (Heroes) (French Edition) a POC culture to Tortall only to have white woman come in Carpe diemL'art du bonheur selon les poètes de la Renaissance and talkbout Signaler un problème all of its social ills is kind of grating Even if the criticism is justified within the logic of the text slavery is bad obvsnd I kind of like that The Jesus Contact a YA fantasy novelddresses it since Recettes Faciles a lot of fantasy worldsre predicated on just Le plus grand défi de l'histoire de l'humanité accepting rigid pre modern social hierarchiesnd while we do get L'Espoir des Neshov 4 at least one sympathetic Cathakian in the form of Kaddar it still kind of bugs that Pierce decides to set up this framework with this booknd this culture The thing Le livre de piété de la jeune fille au pensionnat et dans sa famille about having Tortalls essentially some sort of idealised progressive medieval fantasyland which is super fun don t get me wrong is that it tends to come out looking peachy keen raised up on the moral high ground in comparison to Tu tueras l'ange any other society you introduce into that world especially one based on classical empire I suppose Pierce does do well to put most of that on the doings of one crazed emperor rather than some intrinsic fault in the Carthaki people Also Pierce finally Maintenant u'il est trop tard addresses her weird biasgainst women who she deems under utilise their femininity by focusing on being decorative Signaler un problème and eye pleasing She s written lot of bad Suspect ambitious petty women who like to paint their facend wear beautiful gowns Randy Pausch and contrasted withll the salt of the earth practical women she usually champions in her stories it s kind of Ce ui Est Vivant Ed Ce ui Est Morte De LA Philosophie De Hegel Edude Critiue Suvie DUN Essai De Bibliographie Hegelienne Reprints in Philosoph a telling imbalance At least in this one she finally has Varice speak up in defense of those pursuits of liking pretty thingsnd parties etc That said there s still Signaler un problème a general vibe of the overlyestheticiseddegenerative nd decadent trope in the wealth on display in the Carthaki Empire which might not have bothered me if I hadn t felt those other concerns I detailed bovespoiler The Impossible Boss alertFinally therchival buff in me was like NO NOT THE IMPERIAL RECORDS THAT HAS VALUABLE HISTORICAL DATA Like go for the treasury sure but come on Also did uh ll those dinosaur bones just disappear from the museum t the end Whole ENKI BILAL BUG ENKI BILAL apatosaurus skeletons might be pretty hard to come by in the future I feel bad for the natural historianst the Imperial University I still Bug City absolutelydore this book Wild Magic is dear to me because it was my first book by Pierce but Emperor Mage makes my heart soar every time Zek Kitten Bonedancer the hyenas the Graveyard Hag the reanimated dinosaur bones Signaler un problème and hints of Numair s back story the sumptuous surroundingsnd rot underneath Mon petit train avec Mimi and finally somenswers Réalisez votre site web avec HTML 5 et CSS 3 about Daine s father. Tall Daine puzzles over Carthak’s two faced Emperor Ozorne How can he be so caring with his birdsnd so cruel to his people Daine is sure he’s planning something terrible power hungry scheme And she knows that she must fight this powerful Emperor Mage; the life of her beloved teacher is t risk.
Hey folks I just discovered that apparently I have given some very popular books single star ratings except I haven't How do I know I haven't Because I haven't read those books at all So before you go getting all hacked off at me for trashing your favorites know that I've written GoodReads to find out what's going onI return to my regularly scheduled profileThough I would love to join gro